Criminal justice
We have published an extensive body of research and analysis on women and the criminal justice system, which can be accessed below. We have also engaged with a range of stakeholders, including the Scottish Prison Service, Police Scotland, Scottish Police Authority, HM Inspectorate of Constabulary, HM Inspectorate of Prisons, the Scottish Parliament Justice Committe and Public Petitions Committee, and the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT).
Our work includes research on the loss of robust data on sex in the criminal justice system, Police Scotland workplace policies, and the influence of lobby groups advocating against the recognition of sex in law and policy. In relation to prisons, we have published academic papers and briefings on the Scottish Prison Service Gender Identity policy and shown how the policy-making process failed to consider the needs of female prisoners or staff. We have also produced an extensive body of analysis on the Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act and its likely chilling effects in respect of women’s rights. Our petition to the Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee on the accurate recording of sex in cases of rape and attempted rape, and our supporting evidence and analysis can also be accessed here.
Latest updates and analysis
-
Why does the Scottish Prison Service hold men convicted of murder in the female prison estate? A policy timeline
Introduction On 3 and 4 February, the Scottish Government is heading to court to defend the Scottish Prison Service’s policy (2023) on the management of transgender prisoners. In a...
26th January 2026
-
Statement on the closure of our petition on recording sex accurately in cases of rape
Statement On Wednesday 10 December the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee closed our petition, which called for Police Scotland, the Crown Office and Scottish Court Service to accurately...
12th December 2025
-
MBM response to Police Scotland’s evidence on recording sex accurately in cases of rape
“We are pleased that Police Scotland has moved to support our petition, and the wider principle of accurately recording sex across all crime types, as well trans status where...
12th November 2025
-
Briefing note: Scottish Parliament public petition on recording sex accurately in cases of rape or attempted rape
Introduction On 2 June 2021 we lodged a petition with the Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee, ‘calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to require Police Scotland, the Crown...
5th November 2025
-
Asleep at the wheel: how the Scottish Police Authority responded to the Deep Dive report on sexism and misogyny in policing
Introduction In this blog we look at how the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) responded to a damning ‘Deep Dive’ report on sexism and misogyny in Police Scotland, produced by...
24th October 2025
-
MBM response to Scottish Government consultation on the draft SSI to add ‘Sex’ as a characteristic to the Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act 2021
Our response to the Scottish Government consultation on the draft SSI to add ‘Sex’ as a characteristic to the Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act 2021 is shown...
12th October 2025
-
What is the point of Non-Crime Hate Incidents?
Introduction Following the high-profile arrest of comedy writer Graham Linehan for three tweets, Metropolitan Police Commissioner Mark Rowley called on the government to “change or clarify” the law in...
11th September 2025